Should Anthony Rocca be dumped?

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker

Footy prince/aussie rules, whatever he/they are calling themselves these days, He won't attract the best defender from Carlton and it won't free up Cloke to do the things he does best, it proves you are a half wit mate, both those players aren't playing against Carlton.


I reckon he should be dumped for good mate, he is past his use by date, he is sort of in the same boat as Lucas from the bombers, once the ball hits the grounds these type of players are out of the contest, they no longer hold their marks, and the only thing they do is attract a decent back man to play on them. But players need to contribute and i don't think Rocca has been doing that.

Asker's Rating:

Asker's Comment:

thats what im thinking, he should use his weight alot more and should be taking out defenders as he throws his big frame to the ball, like a young tony lockett once did.

Answer 2

I don't think he should be dumped.

I think Anthony should retire. It looks like the body has given way, and he should leave on his own terms (he was an amazing player a few years back).

He should have a stint in the NFL if he can, just like his brother Sav.

Answer 3

no he shouldn't be cause then the best defender from carlton will be attracted to rocca so that would free up cloke who doesn't get much attention to take marks, kick goals and do the good stuff he does more freely, so rocca should be in as a decoy in the foward line and that could get the pies over the line

Answer 4

yeaa

Answer 5

Whilst he hasnt been playing to the best of his ability its hard to agree to dump him. Collingwood have injuries and they need Rocca to be a focal point on the forward line. He can still cause problems for some teams and who is to say he wont suddenly lift his game and do something unbelievable.

Answer 6

I think he should go with retirement. He's just getting too old to play AFL.

Source(s):

Floreat PICA!

Answer 7

He should be given the option to retire.After all he's been a great servant to the club.

Answer 8

no

Answer 9

no i dont think so

hope i helped