NRL All Stars Team Voting?

Question

Voting has now opened, who are you voting for?

Additional Details

I don't like how you have to vote. You have to pick a 1st and 2nd forward and back for each team.

My votes are pretty close to Knights10. Some of them you didn't want to pick any, others you couldn't pick enough. Does make it difficult with one from each team. Some teams have numerous stars like Storm, Broncos, Dragons, Dogs.. Others have none like the Warriors.

Answer 1

Best Answer - Chosen by Asker

I think its an okay way to go about it. Once Bennett narrows it down it will be more exciting to choose the team then.

I voted for-
BRONCOS: Parker, Kenny, Folau, Winterstein
BULLDOGS: Hannant, Ryan, Kimmorley, Morris
COWBOYS: O'Donnell, Bolton, Gallant, Williams
DRAGONS: Creagh, Young, Cooper, Morris
EELS: Hindmarsh, Moi Moi, Hayne, Grothe
KNIGHTS: Cross, Houston, Gidley, Mullen
WARRIORS: Luck, Lillyman, Vatuvei, McKinnon
PANTHERS: Civoniceva, Waterhouse, Lewis, Jennings
RABBITOHS: Taylor, Pettybourne, Sutton, Best
RAIDERS: Miller, Tongue, Campese, Monaghan
ROOSTERS: Ryles, Nuuausala, Minichiello, Pearce
MANLY: Watmough, Stewart, Bailey, Robertson
SHARKS: Gallen, Tupou, Barrett, Covell
STORM: Hoffman, Lowrie, Slater, Finch
TITANS: Bailey, Friend, Rogers, Harrison
TIGERS: Heighington, Galloway, Moltzen, Lawrence

Since I'm going to the game, I voted for players who I want to see live and hopefully meet. But also some teams just had pathetic backs or forwards so it was hard to choose the best of the worst.

Asker's Rating:

Asker's Comment:

=)

Answer 2

I don't like the voting system either, i think it should have been like the Indigenous team where you select 17 players, or was it 20? either way that voting system was better.
There was a lot of players who i didn't want to put in but had to, for instance the sharks had no one except for Gallen, Cowboys had no one, so it got annoying in the end

but hopefully a good team is chosen, i would list everyone that i chose but NRL.com isn't opening on my computer for some reason so can't log in to see who i voted for

Answer 3

I dont like having to vote like this either because we have to vote for alot of useless players

Broncos Te'o Setu Folau Wallace
Bulldogs: Hannant Stagg Morris Turner
Cowboys: Tamou Rapira Gallant Williams
Dragons: Smith Weyman Cooper Boyd
Eels: Moi Moi Hindmarsh Mateo Hayne
Knights: Houston Faaoso Sau Gidley
NZ Warriors: Rapira Luck Hohaia Vatuvei
Panthers: Civoniceva Pritchard Jennings Lewis
Rabbitohs: Pettybourne Taylor Sutton Talanoa
Raiders: Harrison Shillington Campese Vidot
Roosters:Waerea-Hargreaves Nuuausala Pearce Perrett
Sea Eagles: Watmough Stewart Foran Robertson
Sharks: Tupou Gallen Barrett Morris
Storm: Hoffman Lowrier Cronk Slater
Titans:Laffranchi Minichiello Gordon Tagataese

Edit- Like i said Diet fist theres some useless players i voted for we are entitled to our own opinion and oh you forgot to put your Storm votes up

Answer 4

Pretty annoying how there were so many players that you couldn't vote for. Example, where's Kade Snowden? Also, a bit of confusion over whether some players are backs or forwards.

Broncos: Ashton Sims, Corey Parker, Israel Falou, Antonio Winterstein
Bulldogs: Ben Hannant, Micheal Hodgson, Brett Kimmorley, Luke Pattern
Cowboys: Luke O'Donnell, Matt Scott, Will Tupou, Shannon Gallant
Dragons: Jeremy Smith, Jarrod Saffy, Peni Tagive, Darius Boyd
Eels: Fuifui Moimoi, Nathan Hindmarsh, Jarryd Hayne, Krisnan Inu
Knights: Danny Wicks, Richard Fa'aoso, Junior Sau, Akuila Uate
Warriors: Michael Luck, Ian Henderson, Lance Hohaia, Simon Mannering
Panthers: Petero Civoneciva, Frank Pritchard, Michael Jennings, Luke Lewis
Rabbitohs: Scott Geddes, Dave Taylor, Luke Capewell, John Sutton
Raiders: Bronson Harrison, Danny Galea, Josh Dugan, Daniel Vidot
Roosters: Willie Mason, Nate Myles, Anthony Minichiello, Sam Perrett
Sea Eagles: Anthony Watmough, Josh Perry, Kieran Foran, Michael Robertson
Sharks: Luke Douglas, Anthony Tupou, John Morris, Dean Collis
Tigers: Keith Galloway, Gareth Ellis, Chris Lawrence, Blake Lazarus
Titans: Mark Minichiello, Brad Meyers, Sam Tagatese, Mat Rogers

You could effectively make 4 All-Stars teams out of the votes allowed plus the Aus and NZ captains and vice captains.

EDIT: Foilole, interesting point about the useless players part. I'm assuming that's why you voted for T'eo.

Answer 5

Knights 10 team will do me.
It's amazing how many fellers there are (I was going to say Bruddahs or Bro's but somehow I thought I might get my head punched in)
Ahh takes me back to my old Primary School days running around the Mortlake gasworks, lol.

Answer 6

I agree I found voting highly annoying, I had to pick players I really didn't like much just to fill up the votes. My votes are basically a mix between both Knights 10 and Diet Fist's votes

Broncos: Parker, Setu, Folau, Winterstein
Bulldogs: Hannat, Ryan, Morris, Kimmorley
Cowboys: O'Donnell, Southern, Williams, Gallant
Dragons: Creagh, Smith, Cooper, Morris
Eels: Hindmarsh, Moi Moi, Hayne, Reddy
Knights: Cross, Faaoso, Gidley, Mullen
Warriors: Lillyman, Luck, Mannering, McKinnon
Panthers: Waterhouse, Civonoceva, Jennings, Lewis
Rabbitohs: Taylor, Pettybourne, Sutton, Capewell
Raiders: Shillington, Tongue, Vidot, Campese
Roosters: Myles, Nuuausala, Pearce, Carney
Sea Eagles: Watmough, Perry, Robertson, Bailey
Sharks: Gallen, Douglas, Barrett, Morris
Storm: Hoffman, Lowrie, Cronk, Slater
Titans: Friend, Laffranchi, Harrison, Rogers
Tigers: Ellis, Payten, Lawrence, Ayshford

Answer 7

Yer i agree voting system sucks
anyway i voted for

BRONCOS: Sims, Letu, Folau, Wallace
BULLDOGS: Hannant, Ryan, Morris, Kimmorley
COWBOYS: Tamou, Rapira, Tupou, Gallant
DRAGONS: Creagh, Weyman, Morris, Cooper
EELS: Moi Moi, Hindmarsh, Hayne, Reddy
KNIGHTS: Cross, Houston, Gidley, Sau
WARRIORS: Luck, Rapira, Locke, McKinnon
PANTHERS: Civoniceva, Waterhouse, Lewis, Jennings
RABBITOHS: Taylor, Luke, Sutton, Talanoa
RAIDERS: Shillington, Tongue, Campese, Monaghan
ROOSTERS: Myles, Nuuausala, Carney, Minichiello
SEA EAGLES: Watmough, Galuvao, Roberston, Bailey
SHARKS: Gallen, Douglas, Barret, Morris
STORM: Hoffman, Hinchecliffe, Slater, Cronk
TITANS: Friend, Minichiello, Tagataese, Rogers
TIGERS: Farah, Ellis, Ryan, Lawrence