Explain to me again how the Bible is a guidebook of morality...?


A father a son, devout Christians imprisoned their stepsister in a basement and raped her repeatedly. They believe their actions are entirely in line with the Bible, a book that encourages its followers to treat women as property.

I know you will say these are "bad apples." However, Christians claim that the Bible and Christianity foster moral behavior, and yet we have a many examples like this one where the Bible is used to justify clearly immoral behavior. And, people like these two would argue that Christians who condemn them are the ones who do not understand God's will.


@dewcoons - Your argument about the Constitution is a good one. HOWEVER, you missed an important point. The Constitution was meant to be changed over time. Indeed, the very first thing the framers did was add the first 10 Amendments that form much of the backbone of the American government.

Update 2:

The Bible makes no such allowances for institutional change. Individuals change it to suit their needs, but a sizeable percentage of the Christian population still believes in a literal and hard line interpretation. And, while you and many others dismiss these two men as bad apples, you fail to see that the Bible is used regularly to justify racism, sexism, violence, materialism, and other unsavory acts.

Update 3:

The Bible makes no such allowances for institutional change. Individuals change it to suit their needs, but a sizeable percentage of the Christian population still believes in a literal and hard line interpretation. And, while you and many others dismiss these two men as bad apples, you fail to see that the Bible is used regularly to justify racism, sexism, violence, materialism, and other unsavory acts.

9 Answers

  • 4 years ago
    Favourite answer

    Most of us would agree that the US Constitution is a good source for defining how government should work and what rights people should have, It protects many basic humans rights and defines a form of government that should be response to the needs and will of the people.

    But it has not always been properly carried out. There are the extreme gun nuts who want to take the Second Amendment to mean that they should be able to own rocket launchers and automatic weapons and sell guns to people who are mental ill. There was a time when the US Courts interpreted it to allow slave ownership, support segregation, or to prohibit interracial marriages.

    Those things are NOT the fault of the Constitution, but of the way that people tried to interpret it. Most of those injustices have seen been corrected.

    If you were to poll the people who believe in the Bible on whether or not it has rules that allow a father and son to imprison and rape a daughter/sister, you would find that 99.9% of Christians would NOT believe that is supported by the Bible. Those two are simple nuts trying to twist the text to justifiy their actions. If you were being intellectually honest, you would know that.

    What next? We reject all laws become some sleazy lawyer somewhere tries to twist one to allow his client to "legally" commit a crime? Or we reject all science because some nut somewhere does comes up with an off the wall theory that it points to a science concept to try to support it? Of course not. We are smarter then that. (Or at least such be....)

    The same with this case. You should be smart enough to know that 99.9% of the Bible who actually read the Bible know that it does not support raping daughter or sisters.

  • David
    Lv 7
    4 years ago

    When I read God’s revelation of Himself in the Bible, I realize you and most atheists commit the straw-man logical fallacy. You has misrepresented God—suggesting God is like man in that His moral standards are merely personal, subjective preferences—and then are trying to refute that false idea of God.

    From its first verse, the Bible asserts, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth” (Genesis 1:1). Because God created us and made us in His image, we belong to Him and are obligated to live according to His standard or face His judgment.

    If a fellow human were to arbitrarily decide what morality involves and impose his standard on us, we could say his morality is subjective, according to his personal preferences and beliefs. But because God created us, He has authority over us and has the right to hold us to His standard. We inherently know this ultimate standard of right and wrong because God has written His law on our hearts (Romans 2:15).

    God’s character and moral standards do not change. The atheist confuses God’s rules to man at various stages of the past to His moral character. This is apples to oranges.

    God has always perfectly balanced His justice and mercy—reserving His wrath for unrepentant, unbelieving sinners, and showing mercy to sinners who turn to Him in faith (Romans 4).

    God Himself testified, “For I am the Lord, I do not change” (Malachi 3:6). He didn’t ever think up a moral standard to decide right from wrong. Rather, His moral standard flows from His perfectly pure and holy nature. Since His nature is unchanging, His standard is absolute.

    You will find silly people claiming to be Christian but never read God's Word and rarely are they seen in church and have little idea who God is or what he desires, and certainly has no intention of following God's commands when he doesn't even know what they are. And you want to judge ALL Christians by this person? You're delusional.

    Here is just one moral absolute: God’s moral standard prohibits lying, a standard flowing from His nature that cannot lie (Hebrews 6:18). Yet atheists claim there are no absolutes w/ no evidence or fact of their own whatsoever; in denial of truth and delusional.

    Have you fallen short of God’s absolute, objective moral standard? You can deny it, but you cannot avoid absolutes of truth and morality in science, law, philosophy or reality.

    You could learn nothing true or of value w/o absolute truth. Ignorant atheists show us this every day here with their unfounded, unsupported, illogical, irrational fabricated OPINION.

    If people are silly enough to deny verifiable evidence, they are silly enough to do just about anything and justify it any way they can.

    This is a denial of responsibility issue, not a Bible issue.

  • 4 years ago

    These two SICK individuals will find NO support from the Bible for what they have done...

    In fact, the Bible strongly condemns these offenses with the death penalty. Consider:

    Leviticus 18:6, 17 ays "No man among you should approach any of his close relatives to have sexual relations...You must not have sexual relations with a woman and her daughter. You must not take the daughter of her son and the daughter of her daughter in order to have relations. They are her close relatives; it is an obscene act."

    Deuteronomy 22;25, 26 "If, however, the man happened to meet the engaged girl in the field and the man overpowered her and lay down with her, the man who lay down with her is to die by himself, 26 and you must do nothing to the girl. The girl has not committed a sin deserving of death. This case is the same as when a man attacks his fellow man and murders him."

    Exodus 21:16 "If anyone kidnaps a man [[woman or child] and sells him or is caught holding him, he must be put to death."

    Deuteronomy 24:7 "If someone is found to have kidnapped one of his Israelite brothers and he has mistreated him and sold him, the kidnapper must die. You should remove what is bad from your midst."

  • Anonymous
    4 years ago

    If yo uread the Bible carefully, you'll see the countless entries where it encourages proper moral conduct. Husbands should be faithfull to their wives, and vice versa. Parents should be kind and fair to their children. people should treat others as they would have others treat them. The examples are too numerous to list. There will however always be those that claim to be Christian yet they do not follow the Christian doctrine. Look at it this way. Say a hundred people buy a flatpack wardrobe, they follow the assembly instructions properly, and put the wardrobe together as it should be. Except for one, who failed to understand the instructions, or simply ignored them altogether, and their wardrobe fell apart. Does that mean the instructions are no good?

  • What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
  • 4 years ago

    The Bible shows you of your sin and the only Saviour from sin.

    Is that why you think to discredit it?

  • Anonymous
    4 years ago

    Percentage wise? No.

    It's like I wonder when I travel....how do so MANY have so much

    MONEY? But percentage wise, they DON'T.

    Obviously a person needs to read the NT (for that is

    a big part of what we do as Christians) and then

    do it.

    It's like the girl here on Yahoo who said 'I am a Christian

    and I am 3 months pregnant and want an abortion'...

    Now, it's NOT the abortion part, but it's the idea you can

    BE Christian and do unchristian things.

    Did you notice how few people SPEAK UP? They see bad

    stuff, say nothing?

    Jesus well explains this. Christians SHOULD?....always be

    in the 'hot seat' because Jesus said 'Whoever LOSES His life

    for MY sake shall find it....' ....and 'whoever SAVES HIS life

    in this world will LOSE it'.

    Those people knew people and nobody SAW anything wrong,

    didn't SAY anything?

    Yes, there's RISK, and quite a lot more today than years ago...

    SAY anything and others gang up, ruin you.

    Well, then...as one person put it....(and this is in my own words

    here because I forget theirs)....'I would rather live ONE HOUR

    and live and speak what I believe, than live a hundred years

    and deny what I think is right.

    There ARE always crazies and if there is craziness, then

    everything the bible says is SKEWED

    HITLER? Hitler had a HUGE library, studied all the time

    (when not doing those other things)....and one of the

    most frequent books there? The bible! Many BIBLES.

    So there is NO OTHER moral guide because this comes

    from God, BUT....that doesn't mean everyone can

    READ IT.

    Do you see this difference?

    God's will MUST line up with what Jesus, Paul, etc. taught

    and I seriously doubt they know ANYTHING about that.

  • Nous
    Lv 7
    4 years ago

    Research shows that the reason humans struggle with emotion to find equitable solutions is pinpointed the region of the brain called the insular cortex, or insula, which is also the seat of emotional reactions.

    The fact that the brain has such a robust response to unfairness shows that sensing unfairness is a basic evolved capacity.

    The emotional response to unfairness pushes people from extreme inequity and drives them to be fair. This observation shows our basic impulse to be fair isn't a complicated thing that we learn.

    It therefore fully illustrates that all humans have morals controlled by the brain and that Christians are entirely wrong to try and claim morals as their own!!!!

    But Christians found a way round it!

    Government statistics show that Christians are vastly over represented in prisons for sexual, violent and fraudulent crime whilst year on year government figures show atheists make up only 2% of the prison population!

    The Catholic Church is paying millions in compensation for the sex/paedophile crimes of their priests alone!

    Christians are vastly over represented in the divorce courts!

    Christians invented the concept of sin and then the idea that you could sin, ask forgiveness, get pardoned and start with a clean sheet!

    So no surprise that they are so expert at it is it‽

    A Christian is a man that feels repentance on Sunday for what he did on Saturday and is going to do on Monday. - Thomas Russell Ybarra

    Source(s): California Institute of Technology
  • 4 years ago

    The bible always has to be understood in context. Not only are there people teaching it out of context but people without any proper teaching at all also put it in their own context to justify the things they do. The evil things that people do in the name of the Bible does not make the Bible evil. it just makes them evil. That's why it's important who you let teach you

  • Anonymous
    4 years ago

    Christians are, morals aside, the least ethical demographic going. Their honesty and good will are sorely lacking.

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.