I'd probably do the same as Candy coated.
You basically have to kill Freddy Krueger, otherwise you'll never be able to sleep safely again.
So that leaves you with two masked psychos. One of them is likely to try and kill you, Jason, so you want to minimise contact with that person, just F him if you have to and get it over with.
And Batman, well actually he's pretty OK, I like Batman. Don't really want to marry a guy, but, there are a lot of positives... for one, he is really really rich. And for the most part he is busy at nighttime, and asleep for most of the day, so you don't really have to hang out with him much anyway.