Should the Supreme Court be able to overturn popular opinion? How often and why should the Supreme Court listen to the will of the people?
- FoofaLv 72 months ago
The Supreme Court only exists because the average citizen is not a Constitutional expert. The Court Justices are appointed for life precisely because that was supposed to keep them above politics and populism. Ergo, SCOTUS cannot consider public opinion when deliberating the Constitutional efficacy of a given case before it.
- out2lunch4now2Lv 72 months ago
The Supreme Court should rule only based on the LIMITED authority granted in the Constitution.
- JeffreyLv 72 months ago
The Court should never consider popular opinion., only the Constitution.
- Uncle PennybagsLv 72 months ago
SCOTUS should never listen to popular opinion. SCOTUS is supposed to rule based solely on the Constitution and the law.
Judges that rule based on anything else are what we Cons call "Activist Judges" and it s totally improper.