For the Hall of Fame?
games played: 2747 over 20 year career
career war: 72.4
highest sinlge season war: 8.0
games played: 1988 over 17 years
hr : 383
rbi: 1311 (weird!)
career war: 72.7
highest single season war: 9.8
They are surprisingly close in career war despite Jeter's 3 more years in MLB. If Walker is about to fall off the ballot entirely, then Jeter should have to wait a few years for induction...but he won't....because his inflated reputation will get him in. I'm a fan of both players.... but the induction process just screams for an overhaul
- Lonesome RhodesLv 67 months ago
Best gay infielder in major league history.
- curtisports2Lv 78 months ago
You're overlooking one CRUCIAL number that isn't even close, and that's hits. No one with over 3,000 career hits who is NOT not yet Hall eligible, tied to PED use, or Pete Rose, is NOT enshrined in Cooperstown. Jeter not only has at least 3,000 while Walker got nowhere close, Jeter stands at #6 of all time with 3465. Inflated reputation, my backside.
- BobLv 78 months ago
I agree that the induction process is at best off and at worst it's a joke,but the rest of what you stated in your "question" is off.
- Random GuyLv 78 months ago
Whenever someone tries to use WAR as part of a argument as what player is better, I'll ask this:
Do you think Higuera should have won the Cy Young over Clemens in 1986? If so then you're an idiot.
- What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
- LegFuJohnsonLv 78 months ago
I suppose if you didn't know one was a SS and another was an OF you make a decent argument. Jeter's 72.4 is Top 10 all time for a SS. Walker's 72.7 is 86th for a OF. (and by all means totally ignore the post season)