Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Entertainment & MusicHoroscopes · 1 month ago

Zodiac is not real. An individual is the combination of 12 zodiacs?

5 Answers

Relevance
  • Janet
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    Your "zodiac sign" is only the sign that Sun appeared to be moving through when you were born.  

    Sun is only one of the 10 "planets" that astrologers look at, and often Sun is not the strongest planet in the individual birthchart.

    Everyone has all 12 zodiac signs in their birthchart, but the stronger influences will be whichever signs had any of the 10 planets moving through them.

    No two people have identical birthcharts, and the Sun sign is only 2% of the total influence on the person.  

    Sun-sign astrology is not real astrology and exists only becuase Sun is the only "planet" whose location matches calendar dates. Everything else .. the other 10 planets, the 12 houses, the 12 signs, and 12 to 24 "aspects" (which are FAR more important than the signs) ... you need to have the exact birthtime, the full birthdate, and the place of birth ...

    and you either spend 2-3 hours calculating all the positions ... or you use a computer program or a website that does free birthcharts.

    So really, Sun-sign astrology is just a way for writers to make money off of people who don't understand astrology.

  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    Think there has been actual research done on astrology stereotyping?

    Non liars do.  The Gauquelin studies - over 40 years worth have produced quite a bit that supports astrology, but if you prefer to keep your head in the sand to maintain your psychological problems, feel free to do so. 

     What organization would you trust to do it right? 

    Your lack of trust is a psychological problem.  Research that is done correctly can be verified as the Gauquelin evidence was last verified about 2009 or earlier and to date no one has challenged it - just lied about it. You know the type.  

    ***************************************

    Re: the question.  Clearly you don't know what a zodiac is. You think the words "sign" and "zodiac" are synonyms.  They aren't. Astrologers delineate birth charts.  Every birth chart contains all 12 signs. The 12 signs make up the zodiac. If you want more than that, pick up an astrology book and read it.

  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    Yes TRUE. I am Taurus but I am like all.hahhaha

  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    Right. No one is 1 zodiac sign. Some people may have some signs that are more dominant than others, but no one is exclusively a single sign. Plus your zodiac sign really only refers to your sun sign. You also have your moon sign, rising sign, Mercury, Venus, Mars etc. This is just one reason why it is not fair to judge everyone who has the same sun sign. Because amongst that 1 sign, you would find a variety of  different personalities. Another reason is because people are brought up differently. A Cancer who was brought up in a caring, loving, warm, healthy environment would be much different from a Cancer with humble beginnings for example.

  • What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 month ago

    Edit: I’m lying? Tell us about the biased data criteria Gauquelin collected and used. No women at all. Is that a lie? Half the population immediately was ignored. Only birthdates before a certain year. Specific ‘professions' only, including priests and athletes that are 'champions'. Small wonder why no women. Do you really expect an organization would finance a replication that strictly follows Gauquelin's rules? His "Mars Effect" was about some planets. The Sun sign is a total non factor. Look it up people.

    An individual is an individual. Think there has been actual research done on astrology stereotyping? What organization would finance? What organization would you trust to do it right? 

    The data will be say so with much that can’t be validated. Even if it could what is the benefits? Would you like it if people hired according to birthdate?

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.