What will happen if the Removable Discontinuity is the same as the Vertical Asymptote?

Example: f(x)=16-4x^2/x^2-4x+4

It is both x=2


Example: f(x)=(16-4x^2)/(x^2-4x+4)

It is both x=2

7 Answers

  • Vaman
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    f(x)=(16-4x^2)/(x^2-4x+4)= (4-2x)(4+2x)/(x-2)^2=4(2-x)(2+x)/(2-x)^2= 4(2+x)/(2-x)

    x=2 is the singular point which can not be removed.

  • 1 month ago





    f(x)=4(2+x)/(2-x), if x=/=2.

    So, if the vertical asymptote x=2 exists, the

    discontinuity at x=2 exists too & vice versa.

    It is obvious that if the discontinuity is removed--

    that means the curve is continuous at that point.

    Thus, no vertical asymptote exists there.

  • 1 month ago

    Hello I recently answered this problem in a test, however I only got 5 out of 10 points because my teacher said that there was a removable discontinuity even though I think that only a infinite discontinuity exist... I just want to know what is correct

  • 1 month ago

    It is not acceptable for someone studying calculus to have trouble with formatting fractions. Do try to focus.

    Generally, a removable discontinuity is called removable because, you can make the function continuous by adding just one point (it looks like a hole).

    So a vertical asymptote is not a removable discontinuity.

    (16-4x^2) / (x^2-4x+4) = (4+2x) / (x-2) goes to infinity as x->2 so it's a vertical asymptote.

     The definition may differ from textbook to textbook though.

  • What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
  • 1 month ago

    A simpler example would be the function f(x) = x/x

    I'd say it's undefined at x=0, but in the limit is equal to 1 at that point.

  • 1 month ago

    Except for x=0, you have given us the equation of a line.

    Let's simplify the function you provided. Division takes precedence.

    16 - (4x²/x²) - 4x + 4

    16 - 4 - 4x + 4

    -4x + 16

    There's a hole at x=0, but no asymptote.

    Perhaps you meant (16 - 4x²)/(x² - 4x + 4)?

    -4(x - 2)(x + 2)/[(x - 2)²]

    = -4(x + 2)/(x - 2)

    x = 2 is not in the domain, but that's okay because you still have another x - 2 in the denominator to create a vertical asymptote at x=2.

    (You also have a horizontal asymptote at y=-4)

  • rotchm
    Lv 7
    1 month ago

    It typically makes a hole. But not always... that's because...

    well, you need to learn to write correctly. Did you really mean 

    f(x)=16-4x^2/x^2-4x+4 ?  (no you didn't btw). 

    Correct that and we will explain further. 

    To you own reply. No, there are no removable discontinuity in your function. 

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.